| Jackson Thoma | Salem University | 2024 |
| Ava Sullivan | Purdue University - Fort Wayne | 2023 |
| Sophia Athans | Manchester | 2023 |
| Gavin Shultz | Muskingum University | 2023 |
| Nate Simpson | Purdue Fort Wayne University | 2023 |
| Graham Brodt | Ohio Northern University | 2023 |
| Jack Haggard | Qunicy University | 2023 |
| Walker Brodt | Winthrop University | 2023 |
| Ryan Birr | Southern Illinois University | 2023 |
| Jackson Wang | Wabash Valley CC | 2023 |
| Jareth Zeigler | Marietta College | 2023 |
| Sophia Athans | Rio Grande | 2023 |
| Gavin Haines | IUPUC | 2023 |
| Dylan Hommel | Manchester University | 2023 |
| Coulter Hamilton | IU Southeast | 2023 |
| Wyatt Elliot | Heidelberg University | 2023 |
| Garrett West | Marian University | 2023 |
| Brad Nardi | Rose Hulman | 2023 |
| Ethan Kimmerle | Wabash College | 2023 |
| Gerry Baltierra | Manchester University | 2023 |
| Jacob Young | Illinois State University | 2023 |
| Steven Walsh | Western Illinois | 2022 |
| Nick Underwood | Danville Area CC | 2022 |
| Tashaun Coleman | Bethel University | 2022 |
| Mason Grant | Muskingum University | 2022 |
| Keenan Leblanc | Grace College | 2022 |
| Sean Gannon | Grace College | 2022 |
| Will McKinzie | Wabash College | 2022 |
| Logan Elsbury | Danville Area CC | 2022 |
| Kenzy Angle | Louisburg College | 2022 |
| Kylar Fisher | Earlham College | 2022 |
| Caiden Toney | Transylvania University | 2022 |
| Oscar Stuart | Wabash College | 2022 |
| Brayton Bowen | University of Indianapolis | 2022 |
| Kaiah Senters | Valparaiso University | 2022 |
| Kelsey Endress | Florida Atlantic University | 2022 |
| Kansas Robinson | Northwestern University | 2022 |
| Garret Dalton | Wabash College | 2022 |
| Max Lines | Vincennes University | 2022 |
| Cam VanDergoore | Vincennes University | 2022 |
| Jake Tomich | Wabash College | 2022 |
| Ben Tedesco | Gulf Coast State College | 2022 |
| Audrey Clevenger | John Wood CC | 2022 |
| Dylan Ecken | Barry University | 2022 |
| Charlie Quilliam | Olivet College | 2022 |
| Jackson Kurrasch | IUPUC | 2022 |
| Camden Melvin | Purdue University | 2022 |
| Jacob Young | Parkland CC | 2022 |
| Martino Tobasco | CCBC Dundalk | 2022 |
| CJ O'dell | Lake Michigan College | 2022 |
| Daniel Cross | Franklin College | 2022 |
| Trey Replogle | Rose Hulman | 2022 |
| AJ Sanders | Franklin College | 2022 |
| Dane Stevenson | University of Saint Louis Missouri | 2022 |
| Corey Jeanor | Ohio Northern University | 2022 |
| Jackson Micheels | Bryant & Stratton College | 2022 |
| Nick Sutherlin | Glendale Community College | 2022 |
| Josh Judge | Wabash College | 2022 |
| Blake Nigg | IUPUC | 2022 |
| Braden Rosenfeld | Hope | 2021 |
| Dane Stevenson | Olney Central CC | 2021 |
| Nick Simpson | Taylor | 2021 |
| Nick Sutherlin | Olney Central CC | 2021 |
| Nolan Harris | Olney Central CC | 2021 |
| Ty Matthews | Indiana Wesleyan | 2021 |
| Blake Fuller | Bryant & Stratton College | 2021 |
| Nicholas Mitchell | Western Illinois | 2021 |
| Sam Benedict | Wabash College | 2021 |
| Noah Clark | Vincennes University | 2021 |
| Viv Harris | Marion | 2021 |
| Cam Crick | Asbury | 2021 |
| Carter Giacone | Hanover | 2021 |
| Gavin Lengacher | Hanover College | 2021 |
| Jason Dettman | Misericordia University | 2021 |
| Jackson Parent | Oakland City University | 2021 |
| Riley Bennett | Trine University | 2021 |
| Chris Adams | Marion University | 2021 |
| Anthony Costello | Anderson U | 2021 |
| Gavin Pierson | Wabash | 2021 |
| Jackson Micheels | Danville Area CC | 2021 |
| Caden Bradley | Marian University | 2021 |
| Dane Dubois | Trine | 2021 |
| Dominic Skinner | Trine | 2021 |
| Zach Bielecki | Wabash College | 2021 |
| Luke Shelton | Lincoln Trail CC | 2021 |
| Bishop Akers | Hanover College | 2021 |
| Blake Nigg | Danville Area CC | 2021 |
| Riley Western | Missouri Baptist University | 2021 |
| Ian Scott | Grace (Basketball) | 2021 |
| Joel Hunt | St. Francis University | 2021 |
| Blake Binkowski | Millikin University | 2021 |
| Tyler House | Ohio Christian University | 2021 |
| Preston Jarvis | Murray State | 2021 |
| Tommy O'Conner | Cincinatti | 2020 |
| Kerrington Cross | Cincinatti | 2020 |
| Jacob Young | Dallas Baptist | 2020 |
| Marah Wood | Evansville | 2020 |
| Cooper Thacker | Southern Indiana | 2020 |
| Corey Jeaner | Ashland | 2020 |
| Braden Feltner | Indiana Wesleyan | 2020 |
| Parker Gryskevich | Wittenberg | 2020 |
| Mitchell Baker | Manchester | 2020 |
| Tyler Rhoades | Hanover | 2020 |
| Travis Bevington | Anderson | 2020 |
| Zach Bellini | Pomona-Pitzer | 2020 |
| Kamden Early | Wabash | 2020 |
| Camden Melvin | New Mexico JC | 2020 |
| Riley Mertl | Frontier CC | 2020 |
| Brady Coram | Danville Area CC | 2020 |
| AJ Sanders | Lincoln Trail CC | 2020 |
| Aidan Carlisle | Lincoln Trail CC | 2020 |
| Evan Tremain | Grace | 2020 |
| Austin Carr | Grace | 2020 |
| Logan Brown | Judson | 2020 |
| Brennan Moran | Spring Arbor | 2020 |
| Sean Azcui | Marian | 2020 |
| Jack Henninger | Marian | 2020 |
| Nolan Denbo | Calumet | 2020 |
| Alec Caparella | Saint Rose | 2020 |
| Andrew Coughlan | Lincoln Trail CC | 2020 |
| Brayden Demier | Southern Indiana | 2020 |
| Matt Hall | Ashland | 2020 |
| Ryan Glithero | Goshen | 2020 |
| Tyler Wick | Franklin | 2020 |
| Alex Reed | Franklin | 2020 |
| Ben Richards | Jefferson CC | 2020 |
| Alex Vela | University of Indianapolis | 2020 |
| Rylan Compton | Cedarville | 2019 |
| Peyton Jackson | Manchester | 2019 |
| Brianna Eldridge | Wilmington | 2019 |
| Ryan Nastav | Manchester | 2019 |
| Peyton Blinn | Ivy Tech Northeast | 2019 |
| Michael Oliger | Indiana Tech | 2019 |
| Jake Bilsland | MidAmerica nazarene | 2019 |
| Cameron Ginter | University of Indianapolis | 2019 |
| Tarron Lawson | Eastern Illinois | 2018 |
| Kyle Richardson | ETSU | 2018 |
| Sydney Rodeghier | Indianapolis | 2018 |
| Jordan Jones | Danville Area CC | 2018 |
| Garret Copely | Danville Area CC | 2018 |
| Nick Fuller | Kishwaukee CC | 2018 |
| Jake Sims | IU Kokomo | 2018 |
| Noah Navarro | Ball State | 2017 |
| Spencer Strobel | IPFW | 2017 |
| Roy Thurman | Akron | 2017 |
| Dylan Nanny | Western Carolina | 2017 |
| Damon Maynard | Quincy University | 2017 |
| Logan Kabrich | Rose Hulman | 2017 |
| Sydney Lowe | Indiana Wesleyan | 2017 |
| Krae Sparks | Franklin | 2017 |
| Lexi Gross | Anderson | 2017 |
| Brevin Shackleford | Vincennes CC | 2017 |
| Mitch Duncan | IU Kokomo | 2017 |
| Shelby Baker | IU South Bend | 2017 |
| Derek Wagner | IU Southeast | 2017 |
| Carter Cooper | Wright State - Lake Campus | 2017 |
| Q Kahi'au Quartero | Marian University | 2017 |
| RJ Wagner | Dayton | 2016 |
| Robert Young | IPFW | 2016 |
| Jackson Blevins | St. Joeseph's | 2016 |
| Makenzi Nyland | Manchester | 2016 |
| Brady Bain | Wabash Valley CC | 2016 |
| Owen Gilbert | Marian | 2016 |
| Taylor Astell | IU South Bend | 2016 |
| Caleb Sampen | Wright State | 2015 |
| Jordan Deal | Ball State | 2015 |
| Jackson McGowan | Purdue | 2015 |
| Jack Rude | Samford | 2015 |
| Nick Handlon | Ball State | 2015 |
| Triston Polley | Indiana State | 2015 |
| Michael Klayer | Moorehead State | 2015 |
| Connor Currier | Western Illinois | 2015 |
| Kyle Matter | St. Joeseph's | 2015 |
| Nik Johnson | Ancilla | 2015 |
| JT Truran | Franklin | 2015 |
| CJ Vaughn | Wabash Valley CC | 2015 |
| Pete Wissell | Vincennes CC | 2015 |
| Kiah Ferrell | IU South Bend | 2015 |
| Hunter Speer | William Carey University | 2015 |
| Austin Jones | Anderson | 2014 |
| Sam Sampen | West Virginia | 2013 |
| Gabe Burkardt | Western Illinois | 2013 |
| Tasker Strobel | St. Joeseph's | 2013 |
| Charlie Brewer | Wabash | 2013 |
| Brooks Bireley | Anderson | 2013 |
| Dalton Carter | Earlham | 2013 |
| Sam Comer | Depauw | 2013 |
| Bryce Pennington | Parkland CC | 2013 |
| Levi Baumer | Taylor | 2013 |
| Parker Dunshee | Wake Forest University | 2013 |
| Westin Edrington | University of Nebraska | 2013 |
| Cory Malcom | Arkansas Little Rock | 2013 |
| Alex Krupa | Indiana University | 2013 |
| Curtis Irving | Ohio State University | 2013 |
| Mark Giesler | Dayton | 2013 |
| Kyle Bartleman | Columbia | 2013 |
| Mac Lozer | Michigan | 2013 |
| Rachel Shelley | Anderson University | 2013 |
| Isaac Sampen | West Virginia | 2012 |
| Troy Kuhn | Ohio State | 2012 |
| Clark Pence | Northern Kentucky | 2012 |
| Eric Mckibban | Evansville | 2012 |
| Taylor Lenhart | Central Michigan | 2012 |
| Dylan Whetstone | Indianapolis | 2012 |
| Mycah Whetstone | Indianapolis | 2012 |
| Tyler Whetstone | Indianapolis | 2012 |
| David Oliger | Wabash | 2012 |
| Jake Weimer | Trine | 2012 |
| Logan Coughlan | IU Southeast | 2012 |
| Ryan McCaslin | Otterbein University | 2012 |
| Drew Small | Butler | 2012 |
| Brad McCaslin | Otterbein University | 2012 |
| Jared Miller | Vanderbilt | 2011 |
| Max Kuhn | Kentucky | 2011 |
| Matt Bowman | Wabash | 2011 |
| Tyler Owensby | Wabash | 2011 |
| Tyler Hampton | Wabash | 2011 |
| Andrew Eiler | Anderson | 2011 |
| Ryan McPike | Anderson | 2011 |
| Jason Catron | Manchester | 2011 |
| Tim Johnson | Vincennes CC | 2011 |
| Dalton Wentz | Florida Atlantic | 2010 |
| Joel Stucker | Indianapolis | 2010 |
| Ben Blystone | Heidelberg | 2010 |
| Alex McGowan | Parkland CC | 2010 |
| Tucker Barnhart | Georgia Tech | 2009 |
| Jake Houston | Franklin | 2008 |
| Alex Berlyn | Depauw | 2008 |
| Jeremy Kehrt | Southern Indiana | 2004 |
| Ryan East | Franklin College | 2004 |
| Derek Hankins | Memphis University | 2001 |
| Bill Sampen | MacMurray College | 1981 |
